How we test freestanding ovens

Lifetime score

Our overall score combines test performance (how well the appliance works and how easy it is to use) with predicted reliability (how likely models from the brand are to remain free of faults) and brand satisfaction  (how satisfied owners of the brand’s appliances are likely to be).

Test performance

It’s no good if a product lasts for several decades if it doesn’t work well in the first place. A disappointing product will soon become unloved and unwanted. For this reason, our independent lab testing forms an important part of our overall lifetime score.

Our freestanding ovens test includes:

Oven performance

Using the most appropriate settings for each freestanding oven, we:

• cook pizza at a very high temperature for a short time to assess each oven’s ability to crisp and brown the base while evenly cooking toppings;
• roast a whole chicken to assess cooking of non-uniform food;
• bake scones to test how well the ovens do at high temperatures over a short time;
• make meringues to test each oven’s performance at low temperatures for a long period; and
• grill toast to assess speed and evenness of grilling.

Cooktop performance

Using the most appropriate burner or element on each freestanding oven’s cooktop, we:

• make white sauce to test performance at low temperatures for a long time;
• cook rice to see how quickly temperature is reduced when turned down and whether a consistent heat is maintained at the lowest temperature setting;
• melt chocolate on a very low temperature setting, checking that it doesn’t burn; and
• make a stir-fry to assess the ability to deliver continuous high heat.

Ease of use

We test how easy and safe each freestanding oven and its cooktop are to use, evaluating controls and displays, layout, grill and oven racks, door, handles, and light bulb replacement. We make a note of all functions and features, including anything missing or extras included.

In addition, we assess how easy all components and surfaces (inside and out) are to clean.

Predicted reliability

It’s reasonable to expect a new appliance to remain fault-free for at least the first five years. Our predicted reliability won’t tell you whether your freestanding oven will stop working tomorrow, but it does show which oven brands make models that are less likely to fail.

Brand satisfaction

Satisfaction is important – no appliance should be a source of buyer regret. Appliances with very satisfied owners are more likely to be well maintained. Their owners are more inclined to seek repair for faults than look for a quick replacement.

Repairability (coming soon)

Older appliances are more likely to go wrong, but common faults should be repairable. Repairs should be affordable and convenient – parts need to be easy to find at a reasonable cost, instructions should be available, and repairs shouldn’t need hours of expert labour.

We haven’t been able to assess repairability yet, but it’s important, so we’re gathering data and forming a plan so we can start including it in our lifetime scores.

It will be challenging. We’ll need to analyse product failure data in our reliability surveys, conduct hands-on inspections to evaluate how easy products are to take apart, and investigate which brands make spare parts available at a reasonable price.

Survey data

In our reliability and satisfaction surveys, consumers tell us about faults that have made an appliance they own unusable or mean they’ve had to change how they use it. We also ask them how satisfied they are with the appliance. We use this data to produce our predicted reliability and satisfaction scores.

We use a statistical test to rate the relative performance of each brand. Compared to data we have for all products (of the same type) in the survey, we rate each brand with highest, high, average, low or lowest for predicted reliability and satisfaction respectively.

You can compare the rating of different brands for the same product type (for example, the reliability rating for Bosch and Electrolux ovens), but you can’t compare the results for different product types (for example, satisfaction of Fisher & Paykel ovens and Westinghouse microwaves).

We analyse brands that get at least 30 responses in our survey. That means there are some brands we can’t analyse because we don’t have enough data. For those brands, we assume they have average predicted reliability and satisfaction.

Our data is based on 1,397 responses from owners of ovens in our 2025 survey. Our next survey for ovens is in 2027.